So Scotland is to get an independence referendum to be held in 2014. For people like me, who want a referendum on Britain's (England's?) place in Europe, the wait goes.
But the case for EU withdrawal or radical renegotiation is growing by the day.
Take last week's news that the EU is trying to force the UK government to pay benefits, including pensions, to any EU citizen who applies for them. The EU wants to stop Britain applying its "habitual resident test" to ensure that foreign claimants are genuinely settled in the UK and have paid taxes here.
I think you would be hard-pressed to find more than 2% of the British electorate who would support paying benefits out to foreigners who haven't contributed anything to the country beforehand. But our democratically-elected government is being forced to do so by the European Commissioner for Social Affairs, an unelected Hungarian who we have no influence over whatsoever.
And this is not some minor irritant. Control of public spending, given the size of the deficit and the challenge of funding growing numbers of retirees, is crucial if the UK economy is to survive never mind thrive.
The EU would argue that they are sticking up for the rights of immigrants but the best way to ensure that is to have clear, fair and properly enforced rules to reassure the host country's citizens that they are not being taken advantage of.
A group of Tory MPs recently proposed a scheme where UK immigrants would earn their rights to benefits, housing and healthcare over time by working and paying taxes. They might have added that the immigrant would lose these rights (and ultimately their right to reside in Britain) if they committed any crime.
This might seem tough but it would transform the immigration debate overnight. The suspicion that immigrant communities are a drain would lift. Now the very word "immigrant" suggests a burden and a problem but perceptions can quickly change with some clear rules.
Immigration should be a massive plus for Britain. Not just the cultural vibrancy it brings but hard economic benefits - an improved dependency (worker to non-worker) ratio, a better workforce for our companies and lots of imported skills, capital and connections.
A scheme where residency rights for all immigrants, both EU and non-EU, were dependent on contributing to the system and staying on the right side of the law would ensure that immigration delivers these gains and regains popular trust.
But the EU wants us to go in the opposite direction which will further undermine perceptions of immigrants and make mugs out of honest taxpayers. I wish it was a Referendum on Europe we were getting ready for in 2014.
The People's Pledge - EU Referendum Campaign
From the website: Service for Spanish autonomos
Tuesday, October 23, 2012
Sunday, October 14, 2012
What two years flying Ryanair will do to you
Not really me (it's been a while since I was 36 for one thing) but I do fly Ryanair a lot.
You would think two years commuting back and forth between Stansted and Malaga at Michael O'Leary's convenience might take its toll.
Well yes and no.
The downsides to no frills air travel are well known - minimal leg room, a dash for seats, luggage nazis monitoring your hand luggage etc
All true and I can't say that I am a Ryanair fan exactly. There is a certain arrogance about them; they can be almost defiantly rude and wilfully careless of what their passengers and the public think.
My theory is that they like all the bad headlines (like Woman forced to pay £200 to print boarding tickets) because of a perverse kind of logic. If they can be so awful to customers and still book out their routes they must be the cheapest.
And they usually are. That's my first plus point - I shop around and they usually come out cheapest although less so nowadays. All the "cheap" airlines are a lot more expensive than they were only a year or so ago. That's partly the government's fault for putting up the tax remorselessly.
Another plus for me is that, once you know the system, the journey is quite predictable. You know they are strict about hand luggage and pack accordingly. You know you have to get in the queue early to get a good seat (or pay for Priority). You know you have to print your boarding pass.
Finally they have been amazingly punctual. I literally cannot remember the last time they were late either flying into or out of Malaga. It was certainly over a year ago. I have recently started to fly out o Gatwick with Easyjet on a Friday evening (better flight time) and they have been late twice on the trot.
(UPDATE: the first time I flew Ryanair after I published this blog I was delayed by about 45 minutes. I should not have opened my big mouth!)
So (and it pains me to say it because of their lousy attitude) - two cheers for Ryanair.
From our website: Spanish income tax
You would think two years commuting back and forth between Stansted and Malaga at Michael O'Leary's convenience might take its toll.
Well yes and no.
The downsides to no frills air travel are well known - minimal leg room, a dash for seats, luggage nazis monitoring your hand luggage etc
All true and I can't say that I am a Ryanair fan exactly. There is a certain arrogance about them; they can be almost defiantly rude and wilfully careless of what their passengers and the public think.
My theory is that they like all the bad headlines (like Woman forced to pay £200 to print boarding tickets) because of a perverse kind of logic. If they can be so awful to customers and still book out their routes they must be the cheapest.
And they usually are. That's my first plus point - I shop around and they usually come out cheapest although less so nowadays. All the "cheap" airlines are a lot more expensive than they were only a year or so ago. That's partly the government's fault for putting up the tax remorselessly.
Another plus for me is that, once you know the system, the journey is quite predictable. You know they are strict about hand luggage and pack accordingly. You know you have to get in the queue early to get a good seat (or pay for Priority). You know you have to print your boarding pass.
Finally they have been amazingly punctual. I literally cannot remember the last time they were late either flying into or out of Malaga. It was certainly over a year ago. I have recently started to fly out o Gatwick with Easyjet on a Friday evening (better flight time) and they have been late twice on the trot.
(UPDATE: the first time I flew Ryanair after I published this blog I was delayed by about 45 minutes. I should not have opened my big mouth!)
So (and it pains me to say it because of their lousy attitude) - two cheers for Ryanair.
From our website: Spanish income tax
Labels:
budget airlines,
cheap travel,
michael o'leary,
ryanair,
spain,
travel spain
Thursday, October 4, 2012
7 reasons to doubt the oil optimists
Recently I wrote about "Trough Oil": the idea gaining ground that Peak Oil pessimists were wrong and that oil going to become abundant and cheap in the coming decades.
I laid out the causes for such optimism in the original article but in this follow up piece I am focusing on the counter-arguments: why increasingly hard to satisfy oil demand will continue to keep oil prices high for decades.
Secondly the proportion of oil output that isn't actually oil has increased. Natural gas liquids are the main alternative to crude but have about 70% of the energy value which is why they sell for less. Others include ethanol which is only viable thanks to what I would argue are crazy and damaging government mandates which are becoming increasingly controversial as food prices rise.
Other new sources such as US shale production, including 0.5 million bpd from the Bakken fields on the US/Canadian border, are cheaper but they still use a lot of water and energy and exact an environmental price critics say.
It is the marginal cost of the last couple of a million bpd that matters when it comes to setting a minimum oil price and that cost is rising.
Peak oil was never about oil "running out" - it's more that the big (easy) fields are declining faster than new sources can be economically developed. That assumption still looks to hold and preludes the possibility of the oil price ever returning to much below 80$ whatever the economic conditions.
These are so large (50-100 billion barrels or even more) that they alone count as one of the major reasons for Trough Oil optimism. To put that number in context that is perhaps 1/3 of another Saudi Arabia. But the catch is there are thousands of feet of salt rock between the ocean floor and the oil trapped beneath it. Much of the oil is beyond a depth that even "ultra-deep" rigs are currently able to go (7,500m to about 10,000m) and the deeper you go, the more pressure and the more risk. The Horizon disaster happened at just 1,500m. New techniques and perhaps a $1 trillion may be required.
None of this suggests the fight to keep the world's thirst for oil satisfied is going to be either cheap or easy.
In the short term I am a China bear and I think the troubles that afflict that country will have big knock-on impacts through places like Brazil and Indonesia. However long term there is nothing that will prevent the economic rise of the developing world and the consequent increase in competition for scarce resources.
It might be a bumpy ride but the big picture is still one of hundreds of millions of people emerging from relative poverty to something approximating a middle class lifestyle with its attendant consumption patterns: a richer diet, more travel and especially buying a car.
One of the key warnings of Peak Oil pessimists is that the problem of declining output by traditional producers is that they will increasingly consume more of their oil domestically leaving less for export. This was one of the main arguments convincing me that from now on oil prices would stay high and it would get tougher and tougher to supply demand.
And it's playing out just the way the doomsayers predicted. Middle Eastern consumption of oil rose by 55% during the first decade of the millennium more than cancelling out the small declines in the West. Saudi Arabia, which burns oil to generate electricity to power air-conditioning units and water desalination plants, now consumes 3 million of it's 11 million b/d total output.
Transport, including aviation, accounts for about 75% of oil demand. Despite gently declining car use in the West and more efficient vehicles being mandated by governments, demands for oil to fuel transport globally is almost certainly going to rise in the coming decades as it has done for decades past.
We have already discussed the essential reason for this - the growing size and power of the middle classes in the developing world. The only thing that could prevent a remorseless rise in underlying oil demand - apart from the BRICs and other fast-growing countries going into rapid economic decline which seems unlikely - is a switch from petrol/diesel to something else.
Oil optimists point to clear signs that governments and leading major manufacturers are getting behind electric cars. Other alternatives to oil are natural gas, hydrogen and even liquid air.
But the odds are that they will all remain a niche for the relatively well off or environmentally-concerned. This is not because there won't be technical advances in, for example, batteries but because the petrol car economy is so embedded (at such a vast sunk cost) that even a superior form of automobile technology would face a massive struggle to overturn it.
Consider vehicles powered by liquified natural gas which have been around for decades. They do not require any great leaps forward in technology, new refueling infrastructure (many filling stations already sell it) or a new fleet of cars (petrol cars can be converted quite cheaply). And gas - in the US at least - is 1/7th the price of oil. But only a tiny fraction of the US vehicle fleet is powered by gas.
In summary - the global petrol engine population will continue to faster than the increase in fuel efficiency; oil supply from the "easy" sources of the past will continue to dwindle and prices will stay high. This has important investment implications but that will be for another post.
From our website: Spanish pension benefits 2012
I laid out the causes for such optimism in the original article but in this follow up piece I am focusing on the counter-arguments: why increasingly hard to satisfy oil demand will continue to keep oil prices high for decades.
1. The current oil price
If new sources of supply are coming and demand is set to fall, why is the oil price so high? Even with a hard landing in China, crisis in the Eurozone and world trade volumes crashing the oil price is stuck well over $100 a barrel for Brent crude. Most oil traders expect it to remain so for the next couple of years at least - forecast. By comparison weak demand conditions have ushered in $20 or even $10 oil in the past. These market insiders are telling us that the oil market fundamentals are still tight.2. Maybe production did peak in 2005
Oil production has actually risen in recent years but look behind the numbers and there have been changes since the middle of the last decade. Production growth has slowed despite trillions of dollars of investment and Saudi Arabia, long seen as the world's "swing" producer, pumping at record levels. See chart here: world oil supply is not growing very much.Secondly the proportion of oil output that isn't actually oil has increased. Natural gas liquids are the main alternative to crude but have about 70% of the energy value which is why they sell for less. Others include ethanol which is only viable thanks to what I would argue are crazy and damaging government mandates which are becoming increasingly controversial as food prices rise.
3. Production costs put a floor under the price
All the new sources of supply people are talking about come at a price and it is not much lower than $100 in many cases. For example the Canadian tar sands oil extraction process uses a lot of water and energy to make something usable and this can cost $60-80 a barrel. Approximately 2 million bpd now comes from this source so it's not small beer.Other new sources such as US shale production, including 0.5 million bpd from the Bakken fields on the US/Canadian border, are cheaper but they still use a lot of water and energy and exact an environmental price critics say.
It is the marginal cost of the last couple of a million bpd that matters when it comes to setting a minimum oil price and that cost is rising.
Peak oil was never about oil "running out" - it's more that the big (easy) fields are declining faster than new sources can be economically developed. That assumption still looks to hold and preludes the possibility of the oil price ever returning to much below 80$ whatever the economic conditions.
4. Technical challenges are growing
This is a similar point to 3. but is about the difficulty and danger of extracting new reserves rather than the cost, particularly when it comes to deep sea drilling. The Horizon disaster vividly illustrated what can go wrong with deep sea drilling but perhaps even more pertinent is to look at the reserves Brazil intends to exploit off its Atlantic coast.These are so large (50-100 billion barrels or even more) that they alone count as one of the major reasons for Trough Oil optimism. To put that number in context that is perhaps 1/3 of another Saudi Arabia. But the catch is there are thousands of feet of salt rock between the ocean floor and the oil trapped beneath it. Much of the oil is beyond a depth that even "ultra-deep" rigs are currently able to go (7,500m to about 10,000m) and the deeper you go, the more pressure and the more risk. The Horizon disaster happened at just 1,500m. New techniques and perhaps a $1 trillion may be required.
None of this suggests the fight to keep the world's thirst for oil satisfied is going to be either cheap or easy.
5. Declining consumption in the West will be more than offset
One of the main focuses of optimism on the demand side is that oil consumption in the West is on a declining trend even allowing for the effects of the economic crisis. It is true that high prices, recession and more efficient cars have combined to reduce oil consumption slightly in the US and other developed markets (but by less than 1% between 2000 and 2010 according to one chart I saw). But this has been more than offset by rising demand from China and other fast-growing countries and I expect this to continue.In the short term I am a China bear and I think the troubles that afflict that country will have big knock-on impacts through places like Brazil and Indonesia. However long term there is nothing that will prevent the economic rise of the developing world and the consequent increase in competition for scarce resources.
It might be a bumpy ride but the big picture is still one of hundreds of millions of people emerging from relative poverty to something approximating a middle class lifestyle with its attendant consumption patterns: a richer diet, more travel and especially buying a car.
6. Oil producers keep more of their own oil
One of the key warnings of Peak Oil pessimists is that the problem of declining output by traditional producers is that they will increasingly consume more of their oil domestically leaving less for export. This was one of the main arguments convincing me that from now on oil prices would stay high and it would get tougher and tougher to supply demand.
And it's playing out just the way the doomsayers predicted. Middle Eastern consumption of oil rose by 55% during the first decade of the millennium more than cancelling out the small declines in the West. Saudi Arabia, which burns oil to generate electricity to power air-conditioning units and water desalination plants, now consumes 3 million of it's 11 million b/d total output.
7. Carry on guzzling
Transport, including aviation, accounts for about 75% of oil demand. Despite gently declining car use in the West and more efficient vehicles being mandated by governments, demands for oil to fuel transport globally is almost certainly going to rise in the coming decades as it has done for decades past.
We have already discussed the essential reason for this - the growing size and power of the middle classes in the developing world. The only thing that could prevent a remorseless rise in underlying oil demand - apart from the BRICs and other fast-growing countries going into rapid economic decline which seems unlikely - is a switch from petrol/diesel to something else.
Oil optimists point to clear signs that governments and leading major manufacturers are getting behind electric cars. Other alternatives to oil are natural gas, hydrogen and even liquid air.
But the odds are that they will all remain a niche for the relatively well off or environmentally-concerned. This is not because there won't be technical advances in, for example, batteries but because the petrol car economy is so embedded (at such a vast sunk cost) that even a superior form of automobile technology would face a massive struggle to overturn it.
Consider vehicles powered by liquified natural gas which have been around for decades. They do not require any great leaps forward in technology, new refueling infrastructure (many filling stations already sell it) or a new fleet of cars (petrol cars can be converted quite cheaply). And gas - in the US at least - is 1/7th the price of oil. But only a tiny fraction of the US vehicle fleet is powered by gas.
In summary - the global petrol engine population will continue to faster than the increase in fuel efficiency; oil supply from the "easy" sources of the past will continue to dwindle and prices will stay high. This has important investment implications but that will be for another post.
From our website: Spanish pension benefits 2012
Labels:
anglo american,
oil,
oil price,
peak oil,
trough oil
Wednesday, September 19, 2012
Stansted passport queues set to return
UPDATE: 18th November. Unfortunately the predicted long queues at Stansted passport control are indeed starting to become reality.
I have come through twice in the last week and both times there were large queues. Each time was late at night and the queues, while not long enough to get in the newspapers like earlier in the year, were extensive (and annoying) for a quiet day in November (hardly peak season).
Last night there were not that many passengers but still long queues because they only had two desks open which confirms the suspicion that they are cutting back on staff numbers.
On a final note of discontent, I tried to use the automatic passport control gates and, on both occasions, something went wrong with the machine reader and I had to go through the manned controls. Lots of other people seemed to be having the same problem with this technology which is presumably "the future" for passport control.
Original article:
I regularly pass through Stansted, coming back and forth from Spain, and this Summer have been pleasantly surprised by the lack of serious queues at passport control.
But enjoy the speedy passage through immigration while you can - it may not last.
According to a chatty immigration officer I spoke with last week the queues are set to return as early as this month.
She explained that the Summer's surprisingly short queues were down to extra staff being drafted in by the UK Border Force when things got out of hand in the Spring and made some awkward headlines: Long passport queues unacceptable.
The extra staff, some of which were drafted in from other parts of the UK Border Force, are said to be reassigned back to their normal roles which will leave the queues to mushroom again. I hope not as I have a lot of flights planned including a return through Stansted on Sunday night. We'll see.
Similar reports of forthcoming queues at Heathrow:
http://www.workpermit.com/news/2012-09-10/uk-immigration-insider-predicts-more-queues-at-heathrow
From our website: Spanish Tax Services
I have come through twice in the last week and both times there were large queues. Each time was late at night and the queues, while not long enough to get in the newspapers like earlier in the year, were extensive (and annoying) for a quiet day in November (hardly peak season).
Last night there were not that many passengers but still long queues because they only had two desks open which confirms the suspicion that they are cutting back on staff numbers.
On a final note of discontent, I tried to use the automatic passport control gates and, on both occasions, something went wrong with the machine reader and I had to go through the manned controls. Lots of other people seemed to be having the same problem with this technology which is presumably "the future" for passport control.
Original article:
I regularly pass through Stansted, coming back and forth from Spain, and this Summer have been pleasantly surprised by the lack of serious queues at passport control.
But enjoy the speedy passage through immigration while you can - it may not last.
According to a chatty immigration officer I spoke with last week the queues are set to return as early as this month.
She explained that the Summer's surprisingly short queues were down to extra staff being drafted in by the UK Border Force when things got out of hand in the Spring and made some awkward headlines: Long passport queues unacceptable.
The extra staff, some of which were drafted in from other parts of the UK Border Force, are said to be reassigned back to their normal roles which will leave the queues to mushroom again. I hope not as I have a lot of flights planned including a return through Stansted on Sunday night. We'll see.
Similar reports of forthcoming queues at Heathrow:
http://www.workpermit.com/news/2012-09-10/uk-immigration-insider-predicts-more-queues-at-heathrow
From our website: Spanish Tax Services
Wednesday, September 12, 2012
Spanish pound shops need to raise their game
This matters because the sector is one of the retail sectors' rare growth sectors in tough economic times. Spain's consumers and the Spanish economy generally could benefit from a revolution in the cheap and cheerful sector.
The UK pound shop sector has been revolutionised in the recent past with the rise of chains like Poundland and 99p Store. The additional buying power they have has enabled them to expand their ranges and especially to offer more branded products.
Crucially the big manufacturers have been encouraged to make lines especially for the sector so you get Head and Shoulders shampoo for a pound albeit in slightly smaller bottles.
They are also very dynamic, always looking for new offerings so customers never quite know what to expect. You often end up going in to buy one thing and coming out with half a dozen bargains. On my last trip - to stock up on sweets for the kids (honest) - I was delighted to also walk out with two DVDs of the original Spiderman TV series which my kids love and which cost 5 times as much on Amazon.
Even celebs go to Poundland these days according to news reports. Hard to imagine Spanish celebs going to their local chinese bazaar. These never have anything branded or different and the presentation is woeful - like the contents of a Chinese container vessel have just been dumped into a cavernous warehouse. Not everything is that cheap either.
Before the euro came along there were "100 centime" shops (about 60 c) which stuck mostly to the pound shop model, allowing for inflation. The "hypermarkets" we now get in Spain charge pretty random prices with some of knick-knacks costing 60 or 70 cents but some going up to €1,80 or €2.
The bigger ticket items (like big Christmas present toys or electrical goods) are risky purchases even when the price does seem right as the quality is so variable and there are no guarantees.
I could be way out of touch here and maybe there are Poundland equivalents in parts of Spain that I don't know about. But in the areas I know Spain is being badly served and needs a bargain-retailing revolution.
From our website: Taxation of rental properties in Spain
Labels:
poundland,
retailing,
spain,
spanish economy
Sunday, September 2, 2012
Trough oil?
After decades of "Peak Oil" talk and warnings about a global energy crisis, it has become fashionable to claim the opposite: we are awash with the stuff and a supply crunch has been postponed indefinitely.
This is especially interesting to me as an investor because I largely bought into the Peak Oil theory. Permanently high oil prices and the knock-on effects of depleting oil supplies have been something of a cornerstone of my thinking about the economic future. It's why I made what has so far turned out to be a great call on Shell shares last year - How to ease the pain of high fuel prices.
Roughly speaking the Peak Oilers claimed that oil production would peak at 85 million barrels a day (bpd) around the middle of the last decade as production rates from big fields declined.
There is no shortage of oil left in the ground but most of the big easy discoveries have been exploited and it would be increasingly hard and expensive to keep up production levels. With demand from the developing world, especially China, growing fast a crunch loomed and prices would sky rocket.
As we all know this happened to some extent. Chinese consumption alone rose by 4 mbd in the 2000s and the world's oil producers struggled to keep up which culminated in $147 a barrel oil in 2008 and $100+ prices most of the time since despite the economic crisis.
The 90s when oil went down as low as $10 and rarely exceeded $10 seem like another era and one that will never be repeated.
But crucially producers have responded and oil production has increased. The high prices have attracted trillions of dollars in investment in traditional oil producing countries (Saudi Arabia is producing record amounts), new frontiers (e.g. in Africa), and in deepwater drilling.
Throw in a recovery in production from Iraq, which recently became the second biggest producer in OPEC, increased production of "non-conventional" oil extracted from tar sands and new techniques to increase recovery rates from old fields and you can see why production has continued to increase.
A lot of the "trough oil" talk has been driven by the view from the US where exploitation of shale gas and oil has been something of a game-changer. US oil production peaked at 10 mbd in the early 70s and had been in steady decline to about 5mbd until recently when output started growing again. Imports have been reduced by a third and there is talk of the US being self-sufficient in a few years.
But supply is only one side of the price equation; what of demand and especially this insatiable demand from the developing world? Even on this front optimists see trends that could make oil abundant and cheap again.
I have even seen one article in the New Scientist predicting that, by 2020, oil production will start to fall not because of a lack of accessible reserves but because demand will be declining. That's a radical claim: an oil crunch will be avoided not because we will find new sources of supply but because the world will - in their words - "dump the pump".
Two reasons are offered: increasingly fuel-efficient cars, either because of regulations or through consumer choice, and the rise of the electric car.
Developed world oil demand has started falling already including in the US. Partly that is due to the economic crisis but a trend towards fuel efficiency is a factor and is set to become even more significant as new laws take effect.
Consider US CAFE standards which mandate the average fuel efficiency of cars sold as measured by miles per gallon (mpg). When CAFE first came in during the 70s the requirement was 18 mpg and this was increased gradually to 27.5 mpg by the 2000s although Bush refused to raise this not very demanding target higher.
Obama has not been so lenient on the car industry and the next target (due 2016) is 35.5 mpg. Even stricter CAFE laws will bite from 2017 leading to cars with an average 54.5 mpg and a forecast decline of 11% in US oil demand. The EU has passed similar laws focused on average CO2 emissions across manufacturers' fleets.
So that's how Peak Oil could become Trough Oil - multiple increases in supply meets dwindling demand. Well that's the theory. But should we buy into it and, for example, sell oil stocks which would surely tank in a world of Trough Oil? While there are some undeniably interesting facets of the argument I am sceptical but I'll set out the reasons why in another post.
From our website: Spanish non resident tax
This is especially interesting to me as an investor because I largely bought into the Peak Oil theory. Permanently high oil prices and the knock-on effects of depleting oil supplies have been something of a cornerstone of my thinking about the economic future. It's why I made what has so far turned out to be a great call on Shell shares last year - How to ease the pain of high fuel prices.
Roughly speaking the Peak Oilers claimed that oil production would peak at 85 million barrels a day (bpd) around the middle of the last decade as production rates from big fields declined.
There is no shortage of oil left in the ground but most of the big easy discoveries have been exploited and it would be increasingly hard and expensive to keep up production levels. With demand from the developing world, especially China, growing fast a crunch loomed and prices would sky rocket.
As we all know this happened to some extent. Chinese consumption alone rose by 4 mbd in the 2000s and the world's oil producers struggled to keep up which culminated in $147 a barrel oil in 2008 and $100+ prices most of the time since despite the economic crisis.
The 90s when oil went down as low as $10 and rarely exceeded $10 seem like another era and one that will never be repeated.
But crucially producers have responded and oil production has increased. The high prices have attracted trillions of dollars in investment in traditional oil producing countries (Saudi Arabia is producing record amounts), new frontiers (e.g. in Africa), and in deepwater drilling.
Throw in a recovery in production from Iraq, which recently became the second biggest producer in OPEC, increased production of "non-conventional" oil extracted from tar sands and new techniques to increase recovery rates from old fields and you can see why production has continued to increase.
A lot of the "trough oil" talk has been driven by the view from the US where exploitation of shale gas and oil has been something of a game-changer. US oil production peaked at 10 mbd in the early 70s and had been in steady decline to about 5mbd until recently when output started growing again. Imports have been reduced by a third and there is talk of the US being self-sufficient in a few years.
But supply is only one side of the price equation; what of demand and especially this insatiable demand from the developing world? Even on this front optimists see trends that could make oil abundant and cheap again.
I have even seen one article in the New Scientist predicting that, by 2020, oil production will start to fall not because of a lack of accessible reserves but because demand will be declining. That's a radical claim: an oil crunch will be avoided not because we will find new sources of supply but because the world will - in their words - "dump the pump".
Two reasons are offered: increasingly fuel-efficient cars, either because of regulations or through consumer choice, and the rise of the electric car.
Developed world oil demand has started falling already including in the US. Partly that is due to the economic crisis but a trend towards fuel efficiency is a factor and is set to become even more significant as new laws take effect.
Consider US CAFE standards which mandate the average fuel efficiency of cars sold as measured by miles per gallon (mpg). When CAFE first came in during the 70s the requirement was 18 mpg and this was increased gradually to 27.5 mpg by the 2000s although Bush refused to raise this not very demanding target higher.
Obama has not been so lenient on the car industry and the next target (due 2016) is 35.5 mpg. Even stricter CAFE laws will bite from 2017 leading to cars with an average 54.5 mpg and a forecast decline of 11% in US oil demand. The EU has passed similar laws focused on average CO2 emissions across manufacturers' fleets.
So that's how Peak Oil could become Trough Oil - multiple increases in supply meets dwindling demand. Well that's the theory. But should we buy into it and, for example, sell oil stocks which would surely tank in a world of Trough Oil? While there are some undeniably interesting facets of the argument I am sceptical but I'll set out the reasons why in another post.
From our website: Spanish non resident tax
Labels:
CAFE standards,
electric cars,
environment,
peak oil,
trough oil
Wednesday, August 22, 2012
Mining stocks and China's hard landing
A quick update on some comments I made about China's economy in June: China and the miners - place your bets.It was a time when the argument over China's faltering economy was finely balanced: would growth rates dip and quickly recover (soft landing) or could China be on the cusp of something more serious? I suggested that buying mining shares rather than China funds - like Glencore and Anglo Pacific - was a good way to go if you were feeling bullish.
Events since, including lower than expected industrial output, export and inward investment numbers, have pushed the debate decisively in the direction of the China bears.
So have mining stocks declined? Not really. Glencore and BHP are up 20% and 15% respectively since my article at the end of June. Anglo American is down but there are special factors including a disputed copper mine in Chile. Anglo Pacific is up 8%. Iron ore, coal, oil and copper prices are all up sharply.
So in the short term it looks like the correlation between poor Chinese economic data and mining assets doesn't hold. However stock markets are forward looking and much of the China bad news had been factored in by the time of my article.
The latest rises represent bounces from previous setbacks not renewed optimism. The bounce has been attributed to a belief that the Chinese government will ease policy to keep growth rates up and especially sanction another slew of infrastructure projects which are resource intensive. Another factor is a growing belief that the ECB is prepared to act decisively to head-off the crisis in the Eurozone probably by buying Spanish and Italian sovereign debt.
Where now? In the medium term it's hard to be wildly optimistic about the Euro situation whatever the ECB does. As for the bigger question of how long can China keep growing at 8% plus it seems that the authorities will pull all the levers necessary even if that means maintaining the economy's hideous imbalances in particular the bias towards wasteful investment (nearly 50% of GDP) in property and infrastructure.
Meanwhile the big miners are scaling back on some of their expansion plans to reduce the threat of oversupply. Share price meltdown averted? For now maybe although it doesn't feel like the right time to pile into resource stocks particularly after recent gains.
From our website: A guide to Spain's autonomo system
Labels:
anglo american,
anglo pacific,
bhp,
china,
investing,
investment,
miners,
mining,
shares
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




